> a mother seeks her son's safety and inadvertently finds love
> a bureaucrat seeks answers and finds love
> The son seeks vengeance and finds acceptance
> Themes: nature and the power of love, acceptance, surprises in life and the importance of looking beyond the superficial
> Title: what lies beneath a stereotype, the unexpected
Review: Absolutely wonderfully written story! This is a story with great setting (Canadian wilderness), wonderfully developed characters, and one of the best mystery plots I have read in a long time. This is a full fledged novel, not just a mystery. This is a story of loneliness, the evolution of people's lives, the power of love, and the manner in which people make the small and big choices which change their lives forever.
A murder occurs, journeys begin, nature teaches lessons to all, and the scariest of individuals demonstrate their capacity for tenderness....hence the title. Great read!
Saturday, March 26, 2011
"The Tin Drum" by Gunter Grass - *****
> Setting: Insane asylum post WWII in Germany....and the preceding years of Oskar's life
> published in 1959
> As a boy, Oskar, born in 1924, receives a drum and becomes obsessively attached, using a glass-breaking scream to stop anyone from taking it away
> Oskar alternates between 1st & 3rd person narration when referring to himself
> Book is set up as an autobiography being written by Oskar as an inmate of the asylum
>Characters: Mama, Jan Bronski (her lover, and natural father of Oskar), Matzerath (her husband), Bebra (the midget, clown)
> Bebra recognizes Oskar as having stopped his own growth, forewarns of Nazis, "always take care to be sitting on the rostrum and not standing out in front of it."
> 1934-1938 - Oskar disrupted rallies with his drum from under rostrums, "transforming marches to waltzes"
> Favorite quote, refers to being under his grandmother's 4 skirts: "I was looking for Africa under the skirts, or perhaps Naples, which, as we all know, one must have seen before dying. This was the watershed, the union of all streams; here special winds blew, or else there was no wind at all; dry and warm, you could listen to the whishing of the rain; here ships made fast or weighed anchors; here our Heavenly Father, who has always been a love of warmth, sat beside Oskar; the Devil cleaned his spyglass and the angels played blindman's bluff; beneath my grandmother's skirts it was always summer, even when it was time to light the candles for Christmas or to hunt for Easter eggs; even on All Saints Day. Nowhere could I have been more at peace with the calendar than beneath my grandmother's skirts."
> O tempted people who looked at an item in a shop window by breaking a hole in a window from a distance with his voice....watched them steal the item
> p.130 "... a doorway is the favorite dwelling place of evil"
>p.138 word play with religious symbols is great ....i.e....Jesus as an athlete, champion hanger on cross with "regulation nails"
> p.180...."To remain human without external growth, what a task, what a vocation!"....Signora Roswitha, Bebra's lover
> house of cards imagery....Polish resistance to German invasion
> card playing - repetitive image of ephemeral, chancy nature of life
> vocab: occiput: back of the skull or head, sacerdotal: priestly
> p.247 - I have never been able to look at a building under construction without fancying the same building in the process of being torn down."...Oskar and his anarchic way of thinking
> p.248 "I tend, like everyone else, to make allowances for my ignorance, the ignorance which came into style in those years and which even today quite a few of our citizens wear like a jaunty and oh so becoming little hat.".....Oskar regarding his "importunate feeling of guilt" which "sits on the very pillows of my hospital bed"....guilt of feeling responsible for his mother's and Jan Bronski's deaths....symbolically the deaths cause by the Nazis
> Just as Oskar hid from adulthood in his child-like stature, so too did the German people hide from responsibility for their complicity in the holocaust of WWII
> Oskar's sexual awakening w Maria via "fizzy powder"....wonderful!
> fatherhood....Oskar fathers a son, Kurt (1941) with Maria....she marries Matzerath
> while in Paris, Oskar likened standing under the Eiffel Tower to being under his g'mother's 4 skirts
> June 12, 1944....D-Day, Kurt's 3rd birthday at which Oskar gives him a drum......Kurt whipped him as the Allies whipped Germany
> Oskar joins the adolescent anarchists, "The Dusters"...as their leader, "Jesus", when caught by police he uses his stature to feign innocence, metaphor for defeated Germany
> Matzerath swallows his Nazi Party pin to avoid the wrath of the Russions...he chokes to death on it
> p.404 "It was a jagged pointed lozenge...intending...that he put the Party in his mouth and choke on it....on the Party, on me, his son; for this situation couldn't go on forever." end of the "Fatherland"
> as father is buried, Oskar begins to grow
> Oskar became a hunchback....post-war Germans deformed by past
> sold synthetic honey....false sweetness
> p.436 "...today I know that a postwar binge is only a binge and therefore followed by a hangover, and one symptom of this hangover is that the deeds and misdeeds which only yesterday were fresh and alive and real, are reduced to history and explained as such....".............collective guilt
> p.463 "Oskar...was the shattered image of man, an accusation, a challenge, timeless yet expressing the madness of our century.".....art professor to students for whom Oskar sat as a model
> two sides to human nature......"Goethe" and "Rasputin"
> "The Onion Cellar", a club, all guests peel onions to allow themselves to cry....
> p.525 "It did what the world and the sorrows of the world could not do; it brought forth a round human tear."
> Too many tears led to chaos, releasing too much sorrow, Oskar calmed the guests by drumming them back to their childhoods
> No matter what Oskar chooses to do with his life, he knows he will be heckled by the "Black Witch".....the powerful dark side of life....death
> AMAZING NOVEL!!!!
> LibraryThing Review: This novel ranks among the most brilliant pieces of fiction that I have ever read. A 589 page metaphor for the pain and shame of the German people from the period of WWII. Oskar, the self stunted midget who expresses himself via his tin drum and shatters glass with his voice with a precision not to be believed (Kristallnacht) and who hides in his 3 year old body to avoid taking responsibility for his choices is the epitome of the anarchist. He drums the psyche of the Rasputin and the Goethe in every German. The satiric humor is absolutely brilliant. I caught myself laughing and then self-recriminating because it wasn't funny at all! I will never forget the imagery of Oskar craving the safety of hiding beneath the four skirts of his grandmother, his sexual awakening, and his love of nurses. The themes in this book include: the dichotomy of human beings, fear, shame, love, and the very human struggle to survive our own human frailties.
> published in 1959
> As a boy, Oskar, born in 1924, receives a drum and becomes obsessively attached, using a glass-breaking scream to stop anyone from taking it away
> Oskar alternates between 1st & 3rd person narration when referring to himself
> Book is set up as an autobiography being written by Oskar as an inmate of the asylum
>Characters: Mama, Jan Bronski (her lover, and natural father of Oskar), Matzerath (her husband), Bebra (the midget, clown)
> Bebra recognizes Oskar as having stopped his own growth, forewarns of Nazis, "always take care to be sitting on the rostrum and not standing out in front of it."
> 1934-1938 - Oskar disrupted rallies with his drum from under rostrums, "transforming marches to waltzes"
> Favorite quote, refers to being under his grandmother's 4 skirts: "I was looking for Africa under the skirts, or perhaps Naples, which, as we all know, one must have seen before dying. This was the watershed, the union of all streams; here special winds blew, or else there was no wind at all; dry and warm, you could listen to the whishing of the rain; here ships made fast or weighed anchors; here our Heavenly Father, who has always been a love of warmth, sat beside Oskar; the Devil cleaned his spyglass and the angels played blindman's bluff; beneath my grandmother's skirts it was always summer, even when it was time to light the candles for Christmas or to hunt for Easter eggs; even on All Saints Day. Nowhere could I have been more at peace with the calendar than beneath my grandmother's skirts."
> O tempted people who looked at an item in a shop window by breaking a hole in a window from a distance with his voice....watched them steal the item
> p.130 "... a doorway is the favorite dwelling place of evil"
>p.138 word play with religious symbols is great ....i.e....Jesus as an athlete, champion hanger on cross with "regulation nails"
> p.180...."To remain human without external growth, what a task, what a vocation!"....Signora Roswitha, Bebra's lover
> house of cards imagery....Polish resistance to German invasion
> card playing - repetitive image of ephemeral, chancy nature of life
> vocab: occiput: back of the skull or head, sacerdotal: priestly
> p.247 - I have never been able to look at a building under construction without fancying the same building in the process of being torn down."...Oskar and his anarchic way of thinking
> p.248 "I tend, like everyone else, to make allowances for my ignorance, the ignorance which came into style in those years and which even today quite a few of our citizens wear like a jaunty and oh so becoming little hat.".....Oskar regarding his "importunate feeling of guilt" which "sits on the very pillows of my hospital bed"....guilt of feeling responsible for his mother's and Jan Bronski's deaths....symbolically the deaths cause by the Nazis
> Just as Oskar hid from adulthood in his child-like stature, so too did the German people hide from responsibility for their complicity in the holocaust of WWII
> Oskar's sexual awakening w Maria via "fizzy powder"....wonderful!
> fatherhood....Oskar fathers a son, Kurt (1941) with Maria....she marries Matzerath
> while in Paris, Oskar likened standing under the Eiffel Tower to being under his g'mother's 4 skirts
> June 12, 1944....D-Day, Kurt's 3rd birthday at which Oskar gives him a drum......Kurt whipped him as the Allies whipped Germany
> Oskar joins the adolescent anarchists, "The Dusters"...as their leader, "Jesus", when caught by police he uses his stature to feign innocence, metaphor for defeated Germany
> Matzerath swallows his Nazi Party pin to avoid the wrath of the Russions...he chokes to death on it
> p.404 "It was a jagged pointed lozenge...intending...that he put the Party in his mouth and choke on it....on the Party, on me, his son; for this situation couldn't go on forever." end of the "Fatherland"
> as father is buried, Oskar begins to grow
> Oskar became a hunchback....post-war Germans deformed by past
> sold synthetic honey....false sweetness
> p.436 "...today I know that a postwar binge is only a binge and therefore followed by a hangover, and one symptom of this hangover is that the deeds and misdeeds which only yesterday were fresh and alive and real, are reduced to history and explained as such....".............collective guilt
> p.463 "Oskar...was the shattered image of man, an accusation, a challenge, timeless yet expressing the madness of our century.".....art professor to students for whom Oskar sat as a model
> two sides to human nature......"Goethe" and "Rasputin"
> "The Onion Cellar", a club, all guests peel onions to allow themselves to cry....
> p.525 "It did what the world and the sorrows of the world could not do; it brought forth a round human tear."
> Too many tears led to chaos, releasing too much sorrow, Oskar calmed the guests by drumming them back to their childhoods
> No matter what Oskar chooses to do with his life, he knows he will be heckled by the "Black Witch".....the powerful dark side of life....death
> AMAZING NOVEL!!!!
> LibraryThing Review: This novel ranks among the most brilliant pieces of fiction that I have ever read. A 589 page metaphor for the pain and shame of the German people from the period of WWII. Oskar, the self stunted midget who expresses himself via his tin drum and shatters glass with his voice with a precision not to be believed (Kristallnacht) and who hides in his 3 year old body to avoid taking responsibility for his choices is the epitome of the anarchist. He drums the psyche of the Rasputin and the Goethe in every German. The satiric humor is absolutely brilliant. I caught myself laughing and then self-recriminating because it wasn't funny at all! I will never forget the imagery of Oskar craving the safety of hiding beneath the four skirts of his grandmother, his sexual awakening, and his love of nurses. The themes in this book include: the dichotomy of human beings, fear, shame, love, and the very human struggle to survive our own human frailties.
"The Swan Thieves" by Elizabeth Kostova - ***
> Setting: Washington, D.C., present day and Paris 1870s
> Plot: Man attacks painting @ National Gallery, admitted to psych clinic.....refuses to speak, draws same woman obsessively.....psychiatrist, Marlowe, tries to piece his life together through packet of old letters and conversation with patient's ex-wife and ex-lover
> Loss of aimlessness....used to be enjoyed by leafing through books randomly, replaced by "surfing the net"....is it equivalent? Author says not.....no smell of books!
> awareness of very real lives of people in the past
> dual story lines done very well
> nice info on Impressionism
> Themes: love, art, artists, fate, honor, self-discovery through relationships, choices
> LibraryThing Review: Audiobook.......Mixed review. Interesting enough plot....a psychiatrist tries to unravel the story of his patient who refuses to speak. Let's just say that the psychiatrist breaks every rule of confidentiality known to mankind, and if this artist patient is at all true to form...beware living with an impassioned artist! Seriously, if you are not yet tired of the ubiquitous dual story line, you may find this to be a long, yet enjoyable read. Themes include....life of artists, love, passion, persistence, and obsession.
> Plot: Man attacks painting @ National Gallery, admitted to psych clinic.....refuses to speak, draws same woman obsessively.....psychiatrist, Marlowe, tries to piece his life together through packet of old letters and conversation with patient's ex-wife and ex-lover
> Loss of aimlessness....used to be enjoyed by leafing through books randomly, replaced by "surfing the net"....is it equivalent? Author says not.....no smell of books!
> awareness of very real lives of people in the past
> dual story lines done very well
> nice info on Impressionism
> Themes: love, art, artists, fate, honor, self-discovery through relationships, choices
> LibraryThing Review: Audiobook.......Mixed review. Interesting enough plot....a psychiatrist tries to unravel the story of his patient who refuses to speak. Let's just say that the psychiatrist breaks every rule of confidentiality known to mankind, and if this artist patient is at all true to form...beware living with an impassioned artist! Seriously, if you are not yet tired of the ubiquitous dual story line, you may find this to be a long, yet enjoyable read. Themes include....life of artists, love, passion, persistence, and obsession.
"Bury Your Dead" by Louise Penny - ****
Audiobook......A little slow to start but this Three Pines installment was wonderful. I am not embarrassed to admit that at one point I wept! I love Three Pines!
"The Sound & The Fury" by William Faulkner - *
Well, I can honestly say that I have met my match. "The Sound and The Fury" is considered a brilliant work by many, but I feel like I moved into an entirely new plane of existence, one for which I am utterly unprepared. Faulkner's exercise in removing the dimension of time, not just chronology, resulted in one of the most unpleasant reading experiences I have had in a very long time. I like to read....I love to think about what I read....in this case I found myself thinking about not wanting to read! The only silver lining to this cloud of a novel was that I read the Norton Critical Edition, which contained fascinating information. Jean-Paul Sartre, of whom I am a lifelong devotee, wrote the most helpful essay about the novel. Not helpful enough, however!
"The Italian Secretary" by Caleb Carr - ***
> Carr was commissioned by the estate of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle to write this book
> Setting: Victorian Scotland @ Holyrood Castle
> I love Caleb Carr's use of language, always have
> I could visualize Robert Downey Jr. and Jude Law throughout
> LibraryThing Review: A really enjoyable Sherlock Holmes romp! Apparently Caleb Carr was invited by the estate of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle to write such a tale, and I felt like he did the task more than justice. In the afterword, Carr is also challenged to write a tale in which his own alienist, Kreizler, meets up with Holmes. It would be a wonderful combination of the scientific medical mind and the psychological.
> Setting: Victorian Scotland @ Holyrood Castle
> I love Caleb Carr's use of language, always have
> I could visualize Robert Downey Jr. and Jude Law throughout
> LibraryThing Review: A really enjoyable Sherlock Holmes romp! Apparently Caleb Carr was invited by the estate of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle to write such a tale, and I felt like he did the task more than justice. In the afterword, Carr is also challenged to write a tale in which his own alienist, Kreizler, meets up with Holmes. It would be a wonderful combination of the scientific medical mind and the psychological.
"Room" by Emma Donoghue - ****
> Setting: somewhere in USA, first in "Room", then clinic, then Grandma's house, then Independent Living Apt.
> Jack (age 5) & Ma
> Ma abducted at age 19 by "Old Nick", kept in a backyard one room shed for seven years....1 miscarriage and then Jack.......they escape into the "World"
> LibraryThing Review: What a moving story! The plot is unique and meaningful on multiple levels, from the intrapsychic, to interpersonal, to the cross-cultural, and spiritual. The wonderful thing about this story is that it can be taken at face value, and stand on its own, or be considered as a metaphor for so much of life. Jack (age 5) and his mother, Ma, escape the room they have occupied all of Jack's life and are suddenly thrust into the world. Reading this novel reminded me of the lovely movie, "Being There" with Peter Sellers and Shirley MacLaine. I think the story and its ramifications will linger with me for quite a while to come.
> Jack (age 5) & Ma
> Ma abducted at age 19 by "Old Nick", kept in a backyard one room shed for seven years....1 miscarriage and then Jack.......they escape into the "World"
> LibraryThing Review: What a moving story! The plot is unique and meaningful on multiple levels, from the intrapsychic, to interpersonal, to the cross-cultural, and spiritual. The wonderful thing about this story is that it can be taken at face value, and stand on its own, or be considered as a metaphor for so much of life. Jack (age 5) and his mother, Ma, escape the room they have occupied all of Jack's life and are suddenly thrust into the world. Reading this novel reminded me of the lovely movie, "Being There" with Peter Sellers and Shirley MacLaine. I think the story and its ramifications will linger with me for quite a while to come.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)